NEW BILL WOULD PROTECT PSYCH PATIENTS WHO SUE
New York Post, December 2, 1998
The state's decades-old practice of hitting mental patients with
whopping medical bills when they sue for negligence or abuse is
being targeted by lawmakers.
State Assemblyman James Brennan (D-Brooklyn) is proposing a law to
bar the state attorney general from billing indigent mental patients
for care after they sue for damages in cases that involve everything
from rape to murder.
Brennan will announce the bill at a press conference tomorrow,
highlighting the case of Donald Kaplan, a Kingsboro Psychiatric
Center patient who was stabbed to death in 1994 by another patient.
The killer, who had a history of violence, easily slipped in and out
of the compound and was also able to sneak a knife through lax
But when Kaplan's family sued, the attorney general hit his estate
with a $382,000 bill for past services, even seeking payment for the
"care" he received the day he was killed.
"A prisoner who sues does not have to pay for the time spent in
jail," said Madeline Bryer, Kaplan's lawyer. "Why are we treating
mental patients differently?"
The practice discourages patients and their families from suing and
discourages institutions from correcting abuses, Brennan said.
"The Kaplan case is the tip of the iceberg," he said, noting that
damages outweighed hospital bills in only two cases over the past 20
years. "The state's policy has the effect of covering up gross
One case involved a female mental patient at the South Beach
Psychiatric Center on Staten Island who was sedated, forgotten, and
then raped by another patient in 1992. The victim's $250,000 award
was reduced by $100,000 to pay her medical bill.
The other case involved a 15-year-old mental patient left blind when
his retinas became detached because hospital staff failed to take
measures to keep him from repeatedly banging his head against a
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further
reproduction or distribution is prohibited without permission.
<< Back to News Stories
Attorney Advertising. Prior
Results Do Not Guarantee a Similar Outcome.
Copyright © – Madeline Lee Bryer, P.C. – Attorneys at Law
Serious Injuries, Personal Injury Lawyers, Victims Rights,
Burn Injuries, Lead Poisoning, Burn Injuries, Scald Burns, Violent Crime, Third Degree Burns, Car Accidents,
Wrongful Death, Rape, Sexual Assault, Faulty Designed Products, Medical Malpractice
Consultwebs.com, Inc. – Law webs for law firms, lawyers